all those tracks got big reactions when played live...

and Fighter Beat got released.... wich is being hated by pretty much everybody...

you cant really compare because the two tracks released werent played live...it seems like everyone on this forum worships songs that didnt get released when in fact they might have sounded horrible in studio.

i really dont understand all the hype.

dunno what to say about fighter beat, cos I don´t know it

But it´s thrilling to see, what I will think of this tune. It seems nothing more than a Eddy Cochrane thing I guess

no man eddy is much better. only similarity is constant looping lol.

these tracks should only been released as part of a box set of rarties, i get the feeling the band are holding back a lot of tracks for another album

I get the feeling they're holding a lot of tracks back for their retirement fund ...

both track are pretty weak,we could have had stab or mescaline but instead we got these.they are very aono style,similar to wtf is eddy cochran.i just hope they won't end up as b-sides for the singles,onstead of better tracks

both tracks are horrible especially fighter beat, you just can't release that kind of shit as one of the biggest electronic bands of all time

yes. you can. i mean, they can. and they probably will. more shits to come. so better quit, or got used to it.

agreed these 2 are weak.

Im not mad about that. Im mad that we get an bonus disk, but only 4 tracks. now, there's only gonna be 1 good tune (2 at the most).

I'd rather have a bunch of professional live cuts like Their Law or some of the stuff on the expanded albums.

I like both tracks, they may seem a bit basic compared to other tracks, but still i like them, i think they are unique and cool


BTW, so is Commanche now called ''The Big Gundown'' ? im confused. because liam still calls it Commanche.

okay... 2 really crappy bonus tracks... really... black smoke reminds me of "who the fuk is eddy cockran" and fighter beat is officially the prodigy's worst track...

I love both tracks..for what they are....am I weird?

Fighter Beat has some creepy sounds that are taken from the main theme from Signs (alien invasion movie with mel gibson)....i like that sound alot. Both tracks are really dirty, rockin and really raw in a good way imo. Good as bonus "lost beats" is all im gonna say.

i take them for what they are, binned tracks that we given as a gift to the fans

Black Smoke is pretty good, maybe a vocal sample woulda helped it out. could see it bang live.

Fighter Beat is just strange. i don't hate it. it's just something different from Liam which is cool to hear.

these are binned ideas, so i'm not gonna put too much into it. people should calm down a bit. gonna scare Liam off from releasing more binned material. which would suck even more!

i can only hope Liam is saving the true secret gems for the "Farewell Rare Works Collected!"

Pretty good "demos" I like both, rough, dark, straight from the underground